Changing the culture of our work

Principal Vanessa Fisher and teacher Brianne Dilley are working together at Sunnyside Elementary School in Durango to define their roles and responsibilities to improve teaching and student learning in Colorado’s new educator effectiveness evaluation system. 

Vanessa Fisher & Brianne Dilley

Vanessa Fisher & Brianne Dilley

“Already, with Vanessa coming in and observing, I’ve gotten some great feedback and new lessons I’ve tried because of her feedback,” said Dilley, a first grade teacher and Durango Education Association member in one of the evaluation system’s pilot districts, Durango 9-R.

“That’s making me a better teacher,” added Dilley. “That is the goal, to improve our practice  and our lessons to make them better and more engaging for those kids.”

The team from Sunnyside Elementary joined close to 400 hundred educators from Durango and regional communities at Fort Lewis College in January for a district training conference on teaching strategies called “Theory into Practice”, led by the Colorado Education Association. Teachers and administrators spent the day together in professional development examining instruction, standards, assessments, and evaluations that will be used to measure student learning and teaching effectiveness.

“Today is about putting all the pieces together to help our staff really connect and understand all of the initiatives and all of the state requirements that are going on right now,” said Fisher. “We have to have a shared vision so we can move forward together.”

Linda Barker

Linda Barker

“We’re changing the culture of our work,” said Linda Barker, CEA’s director of teaching and learning, in her opening remarks at the conference.  “All of us are  blurring the lines of what our roles are and  how we work together.  To me, that’s exciting.”

As one of the state’s leading trainers on Colorado’s educator effectiveness law, Barker told the audience the day was ‘monumental’ for an entire district to come together and talk about the teaching practices that make a difference for students. 

“When you go back to your classroom, you’ll have new questions, new thoughts, new assessments, and a new push to think about your practice,” Barker concluded.

Kyle Schumacher, superintendent of Telluride School District R-1, attended with a team of his educators to hear more about what teaching needs to look like and should look like moving forward in this century. 

“21st century skills are not just about technology.  It’s about learning strategies, learning styles, entrepreneurialism and creative thinking.  All of those things I’m excited to hear about” at the conference, said Schumacher.

Telluride performs well on state tests, but Schumacher recognizes the opportunities to grow beyond test scores and prepare students for the global economy. Schumacher said the new evaluation system gives teachers a great opportunity to be on the ground floor of this change and help guide how public education will look in the future.

 “It’s about ongoing professional development,” Schumacher said of educator evaluations. “My role is to help educators see this isn’t about ‘got’cha’, this isn’t about ‘you’re doing something wrong.’  It’s about taking what we’re doing and changing that to better align with the outcomes that we need our students to have.”

Jeff Schell, the president of the Durango School Board, also attended the training and agreed with Schumacher that his board is focused on a belief that “we have a great staff and we can make them even better.”

Schell added he was excited to take part in a training experience with CEA and his local, Durango Education Association.

“What we did today here wouldn’t have happened ten years ago,” Schell observed. “A lot of the adversarial relationships that were there in the past seem to be dissipating as we all recognize that we need to look at student achievement as part of an evaluation process.”

Diana Hill-Wright

Diana Hill-Wright

Diana Hill-Wright, a math and science teacher of 23 years and DEA member, also enjoyed the spirit of collaboration at the conference and seeing her Association move student learning forward with the leaders of Durango 9-R.

“I was thrilled to see the alignment of our teachers’ association supporting teachers for the good of children. To see my association take that on and help us through a new law and new mandates is amazing,” said Hill-Wright. “Being part of this association is huge for our learning curve and growing as a profession.”

NBC Education Nation starts in Denver tonight

NBC’s Education Nation and its annual focus on public education is right in our backyard. Channel 9 TV, an NBC affiliate, is the major partner in the events through April 20.

You can expect to hear a lot about Colorado’s education reforms of the last few years: the recent overhaul of the state’s academic content standards; CSAP-to-TCAP-to-New Assessment changes; the emphasis on literacy and grade-level reading at the Legislature; SB 191 and teacher evaluation; Innovation Schools in Denver. (Wonder if we’ll hear about our billion dollar shortfall in school funding?)

Tonight is the first big event, a Teacher Town Hall at the new Colorado History Center near the State Capitol in Denver. Many Association members will be there. Watch the Teacher Town Hall and participate in a live chat at EducationNation.com or watch the event on Denver Channel 20. It’s tonight from 6:00-8:00 p.m.

Read about all the events this week at the Events section of Education Nation.

April 11: State Board to consider SB 191 teacher evaluation appeals process

Tomorrow the State Board of Education will vote on the appeals process in Senate Bill 191, the teacher-principal evaluation system. The board’s vote is part of the rulemaking process on education legislation. After the State Board’s vote, the new rule goes to the Legislature where the House and Senate will vote on it.

The new law provides for a system to evaluate the effectiveness of licensed teachers and principals. In the past, state law required districts to rate educators as satisfactory or not satisfactory. When the law is fully implemented, principals’ evaluations will put teachers in one of four categories (highly effective, effective, partially effective, ineffective), and a teacher’s nonprobationary status will be based on effectiveness in the classroom.

Beginning with the 2013-14 school year, each district shall ensure that a non-probationary teacher who objects to a second consecutive Ineffective or Partially Effective rating has the opportunity to appeal because, at this point, the teacher is at risk of losing non-probationary status.

President Beverly Ingle’s CEA Journal column (April-May 2012 issue) outlines the district-level appeals panels our Association believes are critical.

Honor the State Council’s work on appeals process by adopting its recommendations
Our Association has supported the work of the State Council on Educator Effectiveness (SCEE) since the council convened in 2010 in connection with Senate Bill 191, the teacher and principal evaluation law. Three CEA members have served on the council for many months on behalf of all Colorado public school teachers: Amie Baca-Oehlert, District Twelve EA; Kerrie Dallman, Jefferson County EA; and Jim Smyth, Mesa Valley EA.

Now the State Board of Education is developing rules for an appeals process that will be part of the new evaluation system. In the last few months, SCEE – not only teachers, also school board members, principals, a parent, a businessman, a university professor, others – crafted well researched, thoughtful recommendations for the process for a teacher to appeal a second consecutive rating of Partially Effective or Ineffective in the new evaluation system.

From my perspective as a classroom teacher, the council’s recommendations are an impressive example of how a large group of people with different interests and expertise can come together and reach consensus for the benefit of our students.

We fully support SCEE’s recommendations for the appeals process. The State Board is considering them and other groups’ ideas from March 30-April 11. CEA has urged the State Board to defer to the council’s recommendations and adopt them. Here’s why:

  • The premise guiding the council’s work is that educators need a fair, credible evaluation system if they are to be effective educators. To make sure that the evaluation system being developed under SB 191 is fair and credible, we believe we need an appeals panel that has an equal number of teachers and administrators on it. This appeals panel would promote shared leadership among teachers and principals and give a teacher an evenhanded opportunity to present information to show that the rating should have instead been “effective.”
  • A teacher who appeals an ineffective or partially effective evaluation rating must be able to put his or her trust in the evaluation process and the appeals process. The teacher must know that the data and evidence the evaluator used to determine the rating was accurate data and the evaluation process was followed.

We do not believe that school districts should use any appeals process other than a panel of equal numbers of teachers and administrators. For example, a superintendent or other district official should not hear a teacher’s appeal and decide whether he or she deserves the ineffective rating.

We expect that the system the council designed and recommended to the State Board may need some adjustment as we travel through the uncharted waters of a new evaluation system, first with the pilot districts and later in statewide implementation.

We are in complete agreement that the Council’s recommended appeals process will meet the needs of our students, teachers, and school districts. We urge the State Board of Education to honor the council’s work and adopt the council’s recommendations on April 11.

For a teacher, the appeals process is an assurance that an impartial panel of one’s peers and administrators thoughtfully reviewed the teacher’s evidence to determine if it warrants a decision to uphold the evaluation rating.

For teachers, the appeals process is an affirmation that Colorado’s teacher evaluation system is thorough and rigorous. The appeals process is a means of demonstrating that we own our profession. We are helping shape our profession, we care for its well being, and we are responsible for its successes or failures.

State Board endorses statewide evaluation system

On Wednesday, the Colorado State Board of Education approved rules and regulations for the implementation of Senate Bill 10-191. CEA is generally satisfied with the outcome of the State Board’s deliberations and final vote. We view the new rules as a first step in implementing SB 191 and in the creation of a comprehensive, high quality, and meaningful statewide system of teacher and principal evaluation.

The framework for the new evaluation system is the core of the work on SB 191 to date. While there are unresolved issues about SB 191, such as how to measure educator effectiveness in non-CSAP subjects, our Association believes that when the law is fully implemented in 2014, we will have a solid statewide system because school districts must meet or exceed the state level standards.

The “statewide” issue arose in September as the State Board reviewed draft rules written by Colorado Department of Education staff. The issue was whether there would be a single statewide evaluation system or if districts would be permitted to have their own systems that skirted the intent of the law. CEA’s position continued to be, throughout recent debate, that the evaluation system must be a single statewide system. Yesterday the State Board confirmed our position.

Our Association began working on teacher evaluation when Gov. Bill Ritter formed a task force before the Legislature even passed SB 191 during its 2010 session. Three CEA members worked tirelessly on the State Council for Educator Effectiveness (SCEE) for more than a year to make sure Colorado’s evaluation system is the best it can be. On behalf of our 40,000 members, we thank Amie Baca Oehlert (District Twelve EA), Kerrie Dallman (Jefferson County EA), and Jim Smyth (Mesa Valley EA) for their contributions to SCEE’s work. These three local association presidents have been working with administrators, parents, students, and the business community on evaluation and are expert resources for our organization.

CEA is committed to continuing the collaborative work begun by the State Council and supporting the work that will be done by teachers and principals in the SB 191 pilot districts. Lessons learned from the pilot will inform the next steps in SB 191 implementation.

CEA members want accountability in public education and in their schools – accountability for educators and for everyone that results in improving the quality of teaching, increasing student achievement, and making schools safer, better places to learn.

Two interactive, town-hall discussions for educators

Sign up for the Education Nation Town Hall - let your voice be heard Sunday

We hope you will join the live Teacher Town Hall web chat at 10:00 a.m., Sunday, September 25 (Colorado time), and tell the public about the teaching profession. The Teacher Town Hall is part of NBC’s week-long Education Nation program.

Register here for the online web chat with fellow teachers.
 
NEA President Dennis Van Roekel will appear on a panel, and it’s likely that at least one Colorado teacher will also be featured. Join them and educators from every state to share your ideas on teaching challenges and opportunities.
 
Join CEA’s educator effectiveness tele-town hall, Wednesday

We’ll hold a town hall meeting over teleconference for Association members on Wednesday, September 28, from 4:00-5:00 p.m., where you can hear the latest developments on Senate Bill 191 and the State Board of Education’s proposed rules for the law. The meeting is timed for the week before the State Board’s October 5 meeting, the last opportunity for the public to weigh in on the law before the board finalizes its rules and sends them to the Legislature.

The State Council for Educator Effectiveness, after working for many months, recommended a statewide teacher-principal evaluation system to the State Board of Education in August. The council designed a single framework for teacher and principal evaluations in a fair, transparent, timely, rigorous, and valid system that every district will use. The town hall meeting will explain conflicts we have with the State Board’s rules  and how educators can act to see the realization of the State Council’s vision.  Plenty of time will be allotted for your questions.
 
When you register, you will get all the information you need for the town hall. Please provide your personal email, instead of school email, at this registration link.

Engage in educator effectiveness conversation, Friday night on RMPBS

We encourage CEA members to tune into a Rocky Mountain PBS program on Friday about educator effectiveness.

It’s “Colorado State of Mind” this Friday night, September 16, from 7:30-8:00 p.m. The regular 30-minute on-air program will be followed by a panel discussion that will feature Michelle Conroy, a teacher in Craig and Moffat County EA member, and Henry Roman, a Denver teacher and Denver CTA president. There will also be a live online chat from 7:30-9:00 p.m., moderated by Alan Gottlieb, publisher of EdNews Colorado, an online education news source.

CEA is a co-sponsor of this program. Rocky Mountain PBS is partnering with PEBC (Public Education & Business Coalition) and EdNews Colorado on this program with the goal of exploring the challenges of measuring educator effectiveness.

You can post questions and comments now and throughout the Friday night live program — and we hope you will.

SB 191 Recommendations: Survey closes March 28

The State Council for Educator Effectiveness is running a short online presentation and survey to gather educators’ ideas about its draft recommendations for a new statewide teacher and principal evaluation system: the first step in the implementation of Senate Bill 10-191.

We encourage all teachers, preschool through high school, to take the survey which is preceded by a seven-minute online presentation.

On February 9, the council presented its draft recommendations on teacher and principal effectiveness to the State Board of Education. The council goes before the state board in April with final recommendations.

CEA has three members on the council: Amie Baca-Oehlert, District Twelve EA; Kerrie Dallman, Jefferson County EA; and Jim Smyth, Mesa Valley EA. These Association members and the entire State Educator Effectiveness Council needs to hear from YOU.

Teacher and Principal Effectiveness Survey-Draft Recommendations

New Radio Ads: “Gifts, Grants and Donations” and “Responsible Reform”

Senate Bill 191 is up for a final vote in the Senate today, and then will be heard in the House Education Committee next week. CEA members continue to tell legislators why SB 191 is an unworkable bill. Here are CEA’s two new radio ads now airing in the Denver metro area: “Gifts, Grants and Donations” and “Responsible Reform.”

Remember to contact your legislators and tell them to say no to SB 191!

Diane Ravitch Visits Denver, Speaks Out Against SB 191

Diana Ravitch, a well-known author and education expert (and former assistant secretary of education in the George W. Bush administration), is in Denver this week.

Ravitch is attending a number of events in Denver, including presenting at CU’s School of Education and the Education and the Public Interest Center in Boulder tonight. Tomorrow morning, Ravitch will attend a public event at Manual High School and will then participate in a debate with State Sen. Michael Johnston at a private lunch hosted by the Donnell-Kay Foundation (register for the Manual event here).

In yesterday’s Denver Post, Ravitch comments on SB 191, saying, “When you attach rewards and salaries to test scores, people will do anything to get the scores up, and it will not lead to better education.”

In a recent post on her own blog, Bridging Differences, Ravitch says, “…If any of our public officials is talking to testing experts, they are likely to discover that their plans to evaluate teachers by student test scores are technically invalid and will produce perverse (but predictable) effects that actually damage learning and are likely to undermine the teaching profession.”

In addition to being an author and speaker, Ravitch is a professor and historian of education at New York University.

Why Senator Hudak Voted No on SB 191

In her sole “no” vote on SB 191 in the Senate Education committee last week, Sen. Evie Hudak  (D-Westminster) voiced a number of concerns. Her first concern is the bill’s reliance on “gifts, grants and donations” to provide funding for the new system of standardized testing called for in the bill.

“Neither the state nor districts currently have assessments to determine students’ growth in every subject that is taught in every school – yet half of the new educator evaluation system is based on these assessments. The cost of creating such assessments has been estimated between $80 million and $140 million,” she writes on her blog.

Hudak  saw what CEA has seen for weeks: SB 191 is an unworkable reform measure that imposes unfunded mandates on our financially-strapped school districts. Our schools, and our students, can’t afford SB 191.

As Hudak so aptly writes, “The state has just reduced funding for schools by $260 million. With staff being laid off in schools, programs being eliminated, class sizes being increased, and schools being closed in some districts, I can’t see how spending money to write new tests is the wisest use of districts’ funds. The bill would also presumably require districts to pay for training for principals to perform the new evaluations, as well as a considerable amount of money for tracking all the new data. It’s an unfunded mandate and the wrong “solution” to the wrong “problem.”

Read Sen. Hudak’s blog post here, and remember to contact your state senators and representatives and tell them to say no on SB 191!

Senate Bill 191 Up For Senate Debate

Last Friday, Senate Bill 191 passed out of the Senate Education Committee by a vote of 7 to 1 (Sen. Evie Hudak, D- was the lone holdout). Yesterday the bill was approved by Senate Appropriations and will be debated on the Senate floor tomorrow.

If SB 191 passes the full Senate, it will be heard in the House Education Committee next Monday. It will go to House Appropriations and, finally, to the full House.

State Democrats have said they want to finish the session early, by next Friday, May 7. The legislature must complete its work no later than May 12. 

Time is running out, so please keep up the pressure on your legislators – both in the Senate and the House – and tell them to vote no on SB 191!

CEA Teachers Rally at State Capitol to Tell Lawmakers, “We Know What Works”

Below is a news release issued earlier today by CEA.

—————————————————————————————————–

This morning, approximately 500 members of the Colorado Education Association rallied on the steps of the State Capitol to demonstrate their support for revising the educator evaluation system in Colorado – and to bring attention to the failure of Senate Bill 191 to address the complexities and costs involved in revising the system.

“The current teacher and principal evaluation system is outdated and broken, and needs to be fixed. It will take a significant financial investment to do it right,” said CEA President Beverly Ingle. “SB 191 says that we should rely on ‘gifts, grants and donations’ to implement the changes it proposes. This is ridiculous. It amounts to unfunded mandates for our school districts, who are already financially strapped. They can’t afford to pay for a new evaluation system now,” she said.

A number of teachers spoke at the rally, including Jenny Campbell, a special education teacher in Cherry Creek School District. Campbell also testified in opposition to SB 191 in front of the Senate Education Committee yesterday.

Speaking of the current evaluation system, Campbell asked, “How can a principal spend four hours in a classroom of students with severe needs and expect to see the true growth they have made throughout the year? How is it adequate to judge and evaluate the effectiveness of a teacher based on just four hours spent in a classroom?”

Campbell explained that the progress and growth she sees in her students aren’t easily captured by standardized tests. (See Campbell’s full testimony.)

Other speakers at the rally echoed her sentiment, saying that SB 191 is the wrong approach.

Ingle emphasized that “CEA has been involved in every education reform measure in this state – CAP4K, longitudinal growth, accountability and accreditation. We know what works in education in Colorado – and SB 191 doesn’t.”

CEA leaders from across the state are in Denver to attend CEA’s annual meeting, which opened yesterday at the Marriott Denver Tech Center.

About CEA

The Colorado Education Association has 40,000 members, the vast majority of whom are K-12 public school teachers. Members also include educational support professionals such as school secretaries and classroom aides, retired teachers, community college professors, and college students who are planning to become teachers. CEA is affiliated with the 3.2 million members National Education Association.

###

Testimony from SB 191 Senate Ed Committee Hearing

Below is testimony against Senate Bill 191 given to the State Senate Education Committee. These testimonies highlight some of CEA’s concerns of the bill.

NEA President to Testify Today on SB 191

As the Senate Education Committee continues its hearings today on SB 191, National Education Association President Dennis Van Roekel will be on hand to offer a national perspective on the type of actions similar to those being proposed in the Colorado bill. Testimony is set to start at 1 pm today with an hour set aside for opponents to SB 191. Live streaming audio of the proceedings is available; click on “Old Supreme Court Chambers” in the lower right corner to listen to the conversation. 

Also, check out CEA’s Twitter stream for coverage of yesterday’s testimony by President Beverly Ingle and Executive Director Tony Salazar.

CEA President in Today’s Denver Post; SB 191 Testimony Begins

Today, CEA President Beverly Ingle has a guest commentary in The Denver Post. Please take a minute to review it and share it with your friends and neighbors!

Also today, the Senate Education Committee begins two days of hearings on SB 191. A number of CEA members, staff and other experts will give testimony against the bill. We’re looking forward to this opportunity for legislators – and others – to hear directly from the people in the classroom who will be directly affected by this bill. If you wish to tune in to the proceedings, you can listen to live streaming coverage here and click on “Old Supreme Court Chambers” in the lower right corner.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 49 other followers